Skip to Content

Did MBG Sink the IHSG? Weighing MSCI Against Fiscal Worries in 2026

A date-by-date look at the IHSG's 42% slide shows MSCI drove the sharpest falls, while fiscal and policy worries, including MBG funding, were a real but secondary factor.
October 23, 2026 by
Vina Wijaya

The IHSG closed 2025 at 8,646.94 and reached records above 9,000 in mid-January 2026. On 19 October it closed at 4,996.61, about 42% below its end-2025 level. Two explanations compete in public debate: government spending, especially the Makan Bergizi Gratis (MBG) free meals programme, and MSCI's actions on the Indonesian market. We tested both against dates, index moves and foreign flows. This is an analysis of market impact only, not a view on MBG as a policy.

The short answer

The evidence points to MSCI, and the market-structure problems it flagged, as the single biggest driver. It explains the sharpest falls and most index-related foreign selling. But it is not the whole story. A large part of the decline built up between February and early June, when oil prices, a weak rupiah, rising interest rates, negative rating outlooks and worries about policy and fiscal discipline, including MBG funding, all played a part. "The IHSG fell because of MBG" is not supported by the data. "MBG and fiscal concerns played no role" goes too far.

Timeline of the big moves

PeriodMain eventsIHSGForeign flow
28-29 JanuaryMSCI freezes Indonesian index changes and warns of a possible downgrade-7.35% and -1.06%, with trading halts on both daysNet sell Rp13.92 trillion in the week of 26-30 January
2-6 MarchFirst week of the Iran war, with oil above US$110 by 9 March; Fitch moves Indonesia's outlook to negative-7.89% for the weekNet buy Rp2.22 trillion for the week
MayMSCI deletes several large stocks, effective 29 May; rupiah near record lows; Bank Indonesia starts raising rates; MBG allocation trimmed-11.92% for the monthNet sell Rp21.09 trillion in the regular market, including Rp8.36 trillion on 29 May
2-5 JuneHead of the national nutrition agency (BGN) removed and its office searched; rupiah past Rp18,000 per dollar-8.69% for the weekNet sell Rp7.38 trillion for the week
16-19 OctoberMSCI proposes Standalone status-11.57% and -3.64%Net sell Rp3.34 trillion on 16 October; Rp7.84 trillion over 14-20 October

The case for MSCI as the main driver

  • The worst days followed MSCI announcements. The falls on 28 January (-7.35%) and 16 October (-11.57%, the steepest since 1998) came in the first session after MSCI statements, with no comparable fiscal news on those days. After the heads of IDX and OJK resigned at the end of January, the index fell another 4.88% on 2 February.
  • It was not a regional sell-off. At midday on 16 October, with the IHSG down more than 10%, Hong Kong's Hang Seng was up 1.21% and Japan's Nikkei 1.85%.
  • Foreign selling clustered around MSCI dates. Foreign investors net sold Rp13.92 trillion in the week of the January freeze and Rp8.36 trillion on 29 May alone, the day MSCI's index deletions took effect.
  • Selling hit index heavyweights. The big banks led foreign selling in January and October, consistent with passive funds cutting index positions. A BRI Danareksa analyst called January's pressure on bank shares technical rather than fundamental.
  • Even Fitch pointed to governance. While listing MBG among spending pressures, Fitch described "recent domestic market volatility spurred by capital market governance concerns".

Compounded, the four sessions right after MSCI's two announcements (28-29 January and 16 and 19 October) took about 22% off the index. The total fall from end-2025 to the 19 October close was about 42%, so close to half of it happened in four trading days directly tied to MSCI.

The fiscal and MBG argument

The fiscal concern is real. The 2026 budget earmarked Rp335 trillion for MBG. By the end of February the deficit had reached Rp135.7 trillion, or 0.53% of GDP, the deepest February deficit since 2017, as spending grew faster than revenue. Moody's (5 February) and Fitch (early March) both moved Indonesia's sovereign outlook to negative. Moody's cited a risk of declining policy predictability. Fitch forecast a 2026 deficit of 2.9% of GDP, above the government's target, and named the free meals programme and front-loaded spending among its fiscal concerns.

The strongest evidence for this view is early June. In the week of 2-5 June, when the head of BGN, the agency that runs MBG, was removed and prosecutors searched its office, the IHSG fell 8.69%, the steepest weekly drop among major global indices. A Sinarmas Sekuritas analyst ranked government policy and political risk as the first cause and MSCI as the third. On 5 June, Finance Minister Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa said negative perceptions of fiscal management, including criticism linking deficit worries to BGN programmes, were weighing on the market. On 8 June, a market report again linked investors' fiscal worries to unclear funding for MBG.

Weighing the evidence

Three points make fiscal fear a weaker explanation for the equity slide than MSCI:

  1. Trimming MBG did not stop the fall. The government trimmed the programme's 2026 allocation on 19 May, a step reported as aimed partly at calming bond investors. The index still fell from 6,370 that day to 5,342 on 8 June.
  2. Fiscal numbers held up while stocks crashed. By the end of September the deficit stood at 1.24% of GDP, yet the biggest crash of the year came in October, on MSCI news.
  3. Fiscal stress showed up more in other markets. In the March slide, foreign investors were net buyers of Indonesian shares, and analysts tied much of the fiscal risk to oil prices from the Iran war, which raise energy subsidy costs.

Even so, the early-June slide had several causes at once: a rupiah past Rp18,000 per dollar, expected rate hikes, oil, policy worries and fears of an MSCI downgrade. BRI Danareksa Sekuritas summed up the first half with four drivers: fiscal risk from higher oil prices, policy uncertainty in mining and exports, negative rating outlooks, and MSCI's deletions. Bank Indonesia's cumulative 100 basis point increase in its policy rate, to 5.75% in May and June, also weighed on valuations.

What this means for business owners

For companies and investors, the main source of risk this year has been market structure: free float, ownership transparency and enforcement against coordinated trading. These are fixable, and they are what MSCI will judge by June 2027. Fiscal discipline still matters for the rupiah, bond yields and borrowing costs, so finance teams should track both rather than look for a single cause. Our explainer on MSCI's Standalone proposal covers the timeline and what to watch.

Defince helps business owners and finance teams translate market and fiscal developments into practical decisions on funding, shareholder structure, tax and financial reporting. Send us an inquiry at defince.id/inquiry or WhatsApp +62 812 9757 4747.

This article is general information based on public sources available on 24 October 2026. It is not tax, legal or investment advice. Please contact Defince for advice on your situation.

Sources

2027 Budget (RKAP) for Indonesian Companies: Build It Around the Tax Calendar
Budget season is here. A practical guide to building a 2027 budget in Indonesia that includes Coretax deadlines, the SPT date and marketplace PPh 22 from 1 November 2026.

Need advice on your situation?

This article is general information. Tell us about your business and Tim Defince will explain what applies to you, in a free online consultation.